50kzone intro - here is a boiling pot of insight and healthy egos thrashing out the merits of the Lustig-fructose thesis and related issue. Lustig himself, as well as various other big name/luminaries of the fitness-nutrition world, take part. The extract below starts with host blogger Alan Aragon's response to Lustig in the comments section of his post. A copy of the article critiquing Lustig follows below that.
----------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------
Alan Aragon permalink
February 7, 2010
On a whim, I emailed Dr. Lustig thanking him for contributing, and I even praised him for his tenacity despite our disagreement. His initial response was cordial, but contentious. The last thing I want to do is spend my time in a private email debate with him. I let him know that the point of our discussion in the first place is to educate the public, so I invited him to re-engage with me over here, for the learning benefit of the readers. He refused.
Here’s the key point I want to level at Dr. Lustig, who I asked to respond again, but probably will not: If you are such an illustrious academician and scientist compared to the “naysayers” of this discussion who are merely “pseudo-scientists”, then your arguments should have stood strongly on the merit of their scientific defensibility.
But, they were EASILY crumbled. Furthermore, valid arguments against your claims were repeatedly ignored. The large gaps in the accuracy of your material were also repeatedly ignored.
You made an extremely weak showing here, and trust me that plenty of, as you say, “real scientists” had their eyes on this discussion, watching in disappointment as your case floundered and essentially got crushed.
With all that said, you’re welcome to come back and attempt to rectify your failure to communicate relevant facts.